Blog v Wiki

October 03, 2018


At some point in your life, chances are you've probably heard this ubiquitous phrase: "out with the old, in with the new." And as time would have it, newspapers and magazines have been faced with the choice of either phasing out or adjusting to the wider audience found digitally. Coming with this influx of new media, however, redundancy has seemingly run rampant with similar, if not nearly identical, forms of communication trying to stand out amongst a herd of sheep. 

With that in mind, two forms of new media at the forefront of discussion are blogs and wikis. Before we delve into the aforementioned similarities, it may be of use to denote their distinctions from one another. Generally speaking, wikis are regarded as the user-generated encyclopedias in which anyone can contribute to a page written about anything. On the other hand, blogs tend to have a reputation of something a bit more personal; that is, they are entries written through the experiences of certain individuals upon which their audience can comment and respond to the blogger's subsequent posts. In the same vein, unlike wikis, which can quite literally have a page for everything, blogs often lean towards a particular theme laid out by the author, whether it be one's lifestyle, baking recipes, fashion, etc.

Now, while these distinguishing characteristics may place them in differing subcategories under a common blanket topic, similarities do in fact exist. Despite both being founded upon user contributions, a commonly known enemy to both is censorship. Within the realm of wikis, this restraint can be seen by the appointment of trusted individuals to "approve public edits before they're published to English-language stories about living people" and the fact that "Wikipedia in the past has frozen some of its pages about people or events that have become sensitive."(Sutter, 1) The limiting on user contributions on a user contribution based site certainly doesn't ring far off from the censoring on blogs as well. In fact, even though blogs are specific towards the blogger's own personal experiences, "[o]ver the years, blogs have been censored or shut down, and several years ago the Army instituted requirements that bloggers register with their commanding officers and submit posts for review." (Dao, 3). 

Similarities and differences aside, both forms of new media play an important role in convergence in today's networked world. Closing in on the gaps of time and distance, blogs and wikis allow people from all walks of life to come together for some common purpose, and as stated by Jimmy Wales (head and face of a wiki-based project), "we are from different parts of the world." (Cohen, 3) This convergence helps encourage a much wider discussion with various perspectives on an assortment of issues that may not otherwise have been raised.

Convergence in new media can also happen on a more local scale with results just as beneficial. In particular, blogs can foster community relations; that is, a more engaged group online with due diligence offline for the betterment of their neighborhood. Case in point being the Brooklyn blog that helped lead to a drug raid, largely in part due to the vigilance of neighbors who posted play-by-plays of happenings near the epicenter. (Wilson, 3-4) 

Personally, I believe convergence can also occur within wikis in ways that have yet to be ventured into. Namely, the systematic detailing of vehicular auto parts (as one example) by users with knowledge in the field. This comprehensive wiki can then be utilized by local police in investigations. To elaborate, I recall a recent case in which a fatal hit-and-run occurred and the only piece of evidence at the scene of the crime was an old car part that a user on Reddit was able to identify (exact brand and year). Thus, having all of this information collaboratively put together may be of use.

References:

  1. Cohen, Noam. "Wikipedia Looks Hard at Its Culture", NY Times, Aug 31, 2009. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/08/31/business/media/31link.html
  2. Dao, James. "Pentagon Keeps Wary Watch as Troops Blog", NY Times, September 8, 2009. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/09/us/09milblogs.html?ref=politics
  3. Sutter, John D. "Wikipedia: No longer the Wild West?", CNN, August 26, 2009. http://www.cnn.com/2009/TECH/08/26/wikipedia.editors/index.html
  4. Wilson, Michael. "Brooklyn Blog Helps Lead to Drug Raid", NY Times, June 26, 2008. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/26/nyregion/26bayridge.html

You Might Also Like

2 comments

  1. "Forefront of discussion" is a phrase that caught my attention. We overlook the psychological aspects of these medias and focus too much on the technology associated with them. Technology is merely a vessel on which we carry out our discussion when the platform on which we create our networks says more than anything. You mention how blogs have a more personal slant while wikis can have anything or be based on a set theme. This means that we used our sociable nature as humans to do something we find the primal need to do:"discuss". We broke down our forms of discussion into a heavily one sided one or community one. In blogs we want to voice our opinions mainly, while giving people the option to add comments on a secondary level. While on the other hand, wikis put everyone on an even playing field.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Although it’s a basic part of the assignment and something I had to define as well, I especially like your definition or, rather, distinction between blogs and wikis. Wikis being a “user-generated [encyclopedia] in which anyone can contribute to a page written about anything”, whereas blogs being more personal — and often under the gaze of that said “person.” With these distinctions, it’s easy to tell why blogs may be more susceptible to being altered to look a certain way, whereas wikis are vulnerable to be altered to spread misinformation.

    I think your wiki idea also supports convergence, as your real life example showcases contributions by people in the internet. I’ve seen many other instances online where people group up together and give their two cents in a thread to better help an “investigation.”

    ReplyDelete

Popular Posts

SONG OF THE WEEK

Message Me

Name

Email *

Message *